Thursday, April 10, 2008

Palestinians were not the only refugees

Following last week's passing of the Congressional resolution demanding equal treatment for Jewish refugees, David Matas writes in the Ottawa Citizen that it is time Canada, as chairman of the Refugee Working Group, abandoned its one-sided support for Palestinians.

"This resolution speaks to the Middle East, but it also speaks to Canada. Canada is the chair for the refugee working group in the multilateral "Madrid" Middle East peace process, which began in 1991 with a meeting hosted by Spain. At a later meeting in 1992 in Moscow, at which 36 different states participated, the Refugee Working Group was created and Canada appointed the gavel-holder. At both meetings, speaker after speaker rejected double standards and endorsed the principle of recognition for both Palestinian and Jewish refugees.

"At the Moscow gathering, then-U.S. Secretary of State James Baker made no distinction between Jewish and Palestinian refugees, stating: "The refugee group will consider practical ways of improving the lot of people throughout the region who have been displaced from their homes."

"The Refugee Working Group defined refugees without distinction between Jew and Palestinian. Refugees were "those displaced as a result of the conflict between Israel and her Arab neighbours."

"Yet Canada, in its chairing of this working group, has ignored completely Jewish refugees from Arab countries. The Canadian government website about the working group begins by referring to "The continuing plight of the Palestinian refugees displaced by the Arab-Israeli conflict." That is the sole focus of the website and Canada's efforts.

"Jewish communities that had lived in Arab countries since one thousand years before the advent of Islam were harassed, hounded, expropriated and expelled from these lands because of the existence of Israel. Anti-Zionists in each and every country throughout the Middle East justified the victimization of their local Jewish populations by portraying them as enemy aliens. Anti-Zionists attempted to intimidate Israel by terrorizing their own local Jewish populations. At one and the same time, these anti-Zionists blamed Israel for Palestinian refugees and created a Jewish displaced population out of a tit-for-tat sense of revenge.

"In the end, there were more Jews displaced than Palestinians. The original Palestinian refugee population is estimated by the United Nations to have been 726,000. The Jews who have been displaced from Arab countries since the advent of the State of Israel are estimated at over 850,000. A further 57,000 have been displaced from Iran.

"Canada has been hesitant to have the working group it chairs address the issue of Jewish refugees from Arab countries for fear that it would complicate the peace process, adding one more issue that needs to be resolved. Yet the very isolation and manufactured uniqueness of the Palestinian refugee population creates a sense of grievance, a foundation upon which other alleged grievances are built. By design, it is an avoidance tactic that masks what continues to be the failure of Palestinians to acknowledge the reality of Israel's existence.

"Canadian officials assert that the plight of the Jewish refugee population has been resolved through resettlement abroad and integration into Israel. This reasoning ignores what is at the core of the plight of Palestinian refugees -- a vehemently anti-Zionist agenda that is code for the destruction of the Jewish State of Israel. Anti-Zionists created a Palestinian displaced population by launching a war against the nascent State of Israel to bring about its annihilation, and then maintained these Palestinians as refugees by refusing their local integration into Arab countries to which they had fled. The anti-Zionism which has generated and maintained the Palestinian refugee problem needs to be confronted directly through an acknowledgement of the reality of two displaced populations.

"As well, redress for refugees is not just resettlement, integration, or money. It is also memory; it is also truth. The right to recognition of the wrongs which have been done to the Jews of Arab lands remains even after there has been resettlement, integration and compensation.

"By adopting a blinkered approach that looks only at Palestinian refugees in isolation from displaced Jews, the Canadian government is neglecting to look at the peace process in its wider context. If one accepts that peace in the Middle East means peace with Israel's Arab neighbours and Iran as much as with the Palestinians, then it is impossible to overlook the issue of displaced Jews.

Read article in full

4 comments:

Eliyahu m'Tsiyon said...

Matas errs by assuming that the Jews were driven out because of the establishment of Israel. Yet Ya`aqov Meroz [spg?- See his article in Malka Hillel Shulevitz' book, called Forgotten Millions??].

This issue reminds me that the Arabs had a principle of collective punishment. That is, if a Jew in Israel did something against them, then they had a right to take out their anger on Jews in Arab lands, etc. In principle, all Jews were responsible for each other. There is a somewhat similar Jewish principle [כל ישראל ערבים זה לזה] but it is not to be applied in the same way as the Muslims do. Anyway, it is funny, isn't it, that the so-called pro-human rights NGOs condemn Israel for doing "collective punishment" against Arabs, whereas it is a Muslim principle to perform collective punishment against dhimmi peoples, subject peoples??

Eliyahu m'Tsiyon said...

addition to above:

Ya`aqov Meroz [?] in the abovementioned book shows that the decision to despoil Jews of their property and expel had been made before the UN general assembly partition recommendation of 11-29-1947.

Anonymous said...

Eliyahu:

Jews in Safed were attacked and murdered in the 1830s, and I'm not talking about an early wave of Ashkenazim either, but of middle eastern Jews who had either returned from Muslim countries or had never left in the first place.

My point is that this has never been a dispute over Jews from Eastern Europe displacing the Arab peasantry and gentry from the land between the Med and the Jordan. It's always been about religion and Jew hatred.

Eliyahu m'Tsiyon said...

Anon, in that same period, in 1834, the revolt against Muhamnud Ali of Egypt's rule in Israel by Arab inhabitants of the mountain ridge, began with looting Jewish property and killing Jews.

http://www.blogger.com/comment.g?blogID=12598830&postID=112316892183623422